Labor Leaders Call Gasoline Import Dependence a “Policy Failure”

California’s growing reliance on imported gasoline is drawing sharp criticism from organized labor, reinforcing CIPA’s longstanding concerns about policies that undermine in-state energy production while sending jobs and economic activity elsewhere. As reported in Extracting Fact, union representatives participating in a UC Berkeley School of Law webinar warned that replacing California fuel production with imports carries consequences for workers, communities, and environmental accountability.

Tim Sbranti, executive director of the Contra Costa Building and Construction Trades Council, called increasing import dependence a “policy failure,” arguing that California should preserve its ability to manufacture the fuels it consumes. Thomas Enslow, representing the California State Pipe Trades Council, similarly questioned treating imports as a long-term answer to the state’s energy needs. Both challenged the wisdom of shifting production to jurisdictions with weaker labor and environmental protections.

The discussion also highlighted the personal cost of refinery closures. Mike Smith, chair of the United Steelworkers National Oil Bargaining Program, described displaced workers struggling to replace their former earnings and benefits. Sbranti emphasized the consequences for surrounding communities when major employers close, reducing local revenues while increasing demands on public services.

For CIPA members, the discussion underscores the need for a policy approach that supports California’s entire petroleum supply chain, from responsible oil production to refining. Preserving those capabilities helps sustain skilled employment and the economic activity associated with meeting California’s continuing fuel needs.

CIPA believes Sacramento should heed these warnings from the workers directly affected by the state’s energy decisions. A credible energy strategy must recognize the value of producing oil and manufacturing fuels here at home, under California oversight, while protecting the workers and communities that depend on those industries.